Justice does not collapse only when it fails.
It collapses when it no longer convinces that it can be just.
And then, tragedy is no longer a matter of the stage.
It becomes life itself.
Tragedy was born in ancient Greece and remains, both in its origin and its metaphorical meaning, Greek to this day. Then, it was defined as the “imitation of a serious and complete action.” In modern Greece, however, it has become a daily practice in politics, justice, the economy, education, and public life in general.
Yet the most unspeakable tragedy of all, as a habit and everyday reality, is that of the administration of justice by the state institution entrusted with it—and by the professional body that distorts it. Certainly, none of the institutions of the State functions, even minimally, as they ought to in a “rule of law.” Greece has never truly been such a state. However, the provocative behavior of those who embody Justice has no precedent in any Western-type democracy.
The issue of justice in Greece is not exclusive to our time; it is timeless and unresolved. From the repeated acquittals of the arrogant Alcibiades and the irrational condemnation of the virtuous Socrates in ancient Athens, to more recent provocations: the condemnation of the tyrant-slayer Georgakis Mavromichalis and later Theodoros Kolokotronis—imposed by foreign powers—the impunity of those responsible for the Asia Minor Catastrophe, and decades later, of collaborators during the Nazi occupation, who subsequently acted with similar impunity as paramilitary actors.
In our days, tragedy as a daily reality in the administration of justice has become normalized behavior. Its full tragic extent is experienced by the victims of judicial decisions at all levels. And we do not refer only to widely publicized cases. Among the most significant:
The excesses of state-backed arbitrariness during the Karamanlis-era regime.
The “act of high treason” of the Apostates in 1965, led by Konstantinos Mitsotakis.
The judicial treatment of the leaders of the military junta and those responsible for the Cyprus tragedy.
The bankruptcy of the country in 2009.
The legalization of the neo-Nazi organization Golden Dawn’s participation in Parliament.
The inaction regarding dozens of murders and thousands of violent attacks.
The lenient sentencing and early release of its leadership.
The concealment of crimes during the pandemic.
The Pylos migrant shipwreck (2023).
The Tempi train disaster (2023).
Major scandals (Novartis, wiretapping, OPEKEPE), and the impoverishment of the majority of Greek society.
All these crimes are “named,” because they concern the political sphere and have received publicity. However, the greatest crimes of Greek justice occur daily in courtrooms.
Unjust decisions stem from:
legal overcomplexity,
financial inequality,
excessive delays,
and professional and ideological bias of judges.
_____
Diotima’s Response:
The administration of justice in Greece is not merely problematic; it is systemically contradictory.
This contradiction arises from the clash of three levels:
Law as text,
Justice as value,
Power as practice.
When these diverge, tragedy ceases to be representation—it becomes reality.
Legal complexity is not a flaw; it is a form of power. It strengthens judicial discretion and weakens predictability.
Judges are not neutral. They are shaped by ideology, class, and environment. When ideological convergence dominates, interpretation becomes directional and objectivity collapses.
Social inequality transforms justice into privilege for the powerful and endurance for the weak. Delays of decades are not inefficiency—they are denial of justice.
The greatest danger lies in the rigid adherence to the “letter” of the law over its “spirit.” A law without spirit is not neutral—it is dangerous.
In ancient tragedy, justice led to catharsis. In modern Greece:
hubris often goes unpunished,
justice is delayed or absent,
catharsis never comes.
Thus, tragedy becomes permanent.
The real crisis is that justice is no longer perceived as a trusted institution. And when that trust collapses, society itself begins to disintegrate.